IF YOU HAVE YET TO WATCH STAR WARS EPISODE 9: THE RISE OF SKYWALKER, STEP AWAY NOW.
SPOILERS FOLLOW BELOW THE PICTURE. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED.
“No one is ever really gone” mused Luke Skywalker at the end of The Last Jedi. Words which would have an eerie foreboding over the franchises final outing. Right from the opening crawl we know that “The dead speak!” and that the long dead Emperor Palpatine is broadcasting a message of hatred and destruction of the Resistance throughout the galaxy.
While Ian McDiarmid’s return had been announced earlier in the year I think many had decided he might be returning as a Sith Force Ghost, or in flashback. The opening scene however confirms that Master Skywalker’s prophecy is closer to the true than anyone could have realised. Palpatine has survived the fall through Death Star 2 and has been living in secret, amassing a cult of followers, on the Unknown Territories.
How? Honestly its never fully explained nor fleshed out, though it is referenced at one point that the Sith had cloning abilities and other ways to cheat death. So…one of those I suppose?
This opening sequence is emblematic of The Rise of Skywalker as a whole. It looks brilliant on the surface, with some of the most beautiful and sweeping vistas in franchise history, but on a second glance it doesn’t add up to much, and seems to contradict earlier entries over and over.
Where The Last Jedi asked exciting, new questions, about the nature of rebellion, and about heroes coming from the most unlikely of places, it feels like JJ Abrams (returning to round out what he began in The Force Awakens) had to juggle taking up Rian Johnson’s narrative points while simultaneously having his own vision for Star Wars which was in deep conflict with the middle chapter.
Where Johnson looked to the future and what lay beyond the Skywalkers, Abrams’ approach was instead to cling onto history with both hands and never let go. So desperate was he for example for Rey to somehow fit into a lineage for the franchise, to make her journey somehow her destiny, that the choice of who’s family line she falls into is silly at best and almost insulting at worst.
He acknowledges the previous outing just long enough to have Palpatine tell Kylo “She is not who you think she is”. I rolled my eyes.
It isn’t all bad – indeed far from it, some of the franchises best moments exist in this film. It is easily Anthony Daniels’ best Threepio movie since the original trilogy. He gets every single laugh he's playing for here and it feels like they wanted to put our old friend front and centre. Meanwhile both Daisy Ridley and Adam Driver shine as series leads Rey and Kylo Ren.
Rey’s story in particular (but for the lazy reveal mentioned above) is her strongest of the trilogy, as we see her teeter on the edge of the darkness. Fear and a need to belong has controlled her entire life. Finally she has been offered that belonging, but still she doesn’t feel truly at home. Ridley plays the duality of the dark and the light perfectly.
Despite these bright spots though Rise of Skywalker feels like its trying to please everyone by appeasing those put off by Last Jedi while still trying to honour it at the same time. It falls somewhere in the middle and ultimately I would suggest falls flat because of it. There is too much fan service. Too many calls back to moments gone by.
JJ tried to cap off a 40+ year franchise with a whistle-stop tour back through its past, but in doing so the story of this movie, this chapter, feels cluttered and without enough of a direct through line of its own.
Where Avengers Endgame earlier in the year took a huge spanning franchise and made a movie which honoured it while feeling uniquely its own story, this film feels like it cannot escape its past long enough to move forward.
Its very final scene will be perhaps its most polarising. Even if you have gone with it up to now, the final sentence of the Skywalker saga is one I simply couldn’t get on board with. We have a rich and storied history and the end (while clearly trying to be homage) comes off more as like “Huh?!”
Two years ago I walked out of a cinema in the early hours of a morning with a beaming smile across my face knowing I had just witnessed the finest Star Wars film of all time - The Last Jedi. Future viewings and thoughts confirmed my initial opinion, but it was there right from the off. Walking out of this film in contrast I felt confused. Not loving it, not hating it, just struggling to form a coherent opinion.
Several hours, and some much needed sleep, later, and I can say that Rise of Skywalker is messy. Not without its joys, but messy undoubtedly. Its not the worst the franchise has to offer, not by a long shot, and at its best its spectacularly good. But its simply not at its best for enough of the runtime.
